Notes on the Blank Verse of Christopher Marlowe, Analysis Of The Article ' Beliefs And Practices Of Brazilian Efl Teachers Regarding Pronunciation, The International Council On Clean Transportation, Ronald Reagan, The Great Communicator Of The United States Of America, For My Breaching Exercise, I Did Something That Is Expected, Meningitis (Cdc, 2016).The Affordable Care Act Allows Children, New Zealand Based Individual Nicotine Replacement Therapy And Population Level Tobacco, My Observation Of Someone 's Listening Skills, William Shakespeare 's The Merchant Of Venice, Impact Of Social Media On Online Consumer Behavior, The Problem Of Inter Process Communication, Western Dominance And Its Effects On The Global Economy, The Elizabethan Er The New Form Of Entertainment, The Los Angeles Area Is A Major Development Boom, Discipline And Punish : The Birth Of The Prison, Peter Paul Rubens: St. George and the Dragon. Biodiversity Is The Variability Among Living, The Magna Carta Is The Cornerstone Of The Individual Liberties, The Life Of A Slave Girl By Robert Jacobs, Accounting Is The Accounting Methods Of Keeping Detailed And Accurate Records, The Roosevelt Administration : Prioritizing Domestic Over Foreign Policy, Overload : The Problem Of Indigent Defense, Osteogenesis Imperfecta ( Oi ) Is An Inherited Disorder Characterized By Extreme Fragility Of The Bones, Analysis Of Jacob Burckhardt 's The Civilisation Of The Renaissance, Family Is The Most Important Part Of Being Social, Codes Of Cultural Behavior : My Choice Of Country, The Cosmopolitan Tongue : The Universality Of English, Psychological Perspectives On Mental Health Disorders, Major Depression And Its Effects On Social Involvement, Evaluation Of A Manager When Planning For Child Care Centers, The Practice Of Music And Enables Artists And Guest Curators, Why Geothermal Energy Is Good For The Environment And The Society, The Good Shepherd And The Bebenburg Youth, Open Sources Intelligence : Open Source Intelligence, Moral Psychology : A Long Standing Rationalist Tradition, Trial By Fire : The Forging Of Modern Physics, The French Revolution And The Radical Stage Of The Revolution, The Case Of Martinez V. Reemployment Assistance, The Christian Disciple, A Follower Of Jesus, The Theory Of Plate Tectonics And Earth 's Crust Displacement, Investigating Patterns Of Mortality Among Women Experiencing Violence, Communication Is An Important Staple Of Human History, Transitioning Of A Silhouette By Langston Hughes, The Conflict Between Nature Versus Human Institution, Safety Net Hospitals And The United States Health Care System. Oxford University Press. T.S. Oxford University Press 1995, "For Lancelot Andrewes" The Oxford Companion to American Literature. Myths organize the way we perceive and, The Root Of How Cami Still Goes About Relationships, Behavior And Developmental Characteristic Questionnaire, President Donald Trump On Muslim Discrimination, Occupational Safety And Health Administration, Arik Air Hr Problem : The Employment Problem. Social Democracy And Its Impact On Social Policy, The Effects Of Social Media On Society 's Society, Biodiversity. Analysis Of Tim O ' Brien 's The Things They Carried, Social Media Use Impact On Reflective Thought, Effects Of School Design And Building Age On Student Learning. Religion 110 James D. Hart, ed., rev. Selected Essays, 1917-1932 is a collection of prose and literary criticism by T. S. Eliot. Eliot Death has been and always will be an interesting and … His name is Archimedes. Abortion : Is A Choice More Valuable Than A Life? The essays were classified as work C119 by Donald Gallup in his bibliography of Eliot… In many respects, T. S. Eliot’s poems “articulated the disillusionment of a younger post-World-War-I generation with the values and conventions—both literary and social—of the Victorian era” (American National). Selected Essays was placed fourth in the Intercollegiate Studies Institute's Fifty Best Books of the Century and sixth in Modern Library's Best 20th-Century Nonfiction.. His father was president of a brick making company. Added by sudodds (all notes from this user) on 23rd November, 2016 and since downloaded 4419 times. Edited by Dinah Birch. We need to demonstrate to the reader that the examples from the text demonstrate its CANONICAL STATUS and TEXTUAL INTEGRITY. To divert interest from the poet to the poetry is a laudable aim: for it would … Ts eliot essays for application engineering manager resume October 10, 2020 dissertation review service help This theory came from families of painters, as well essays ts eliot as enrichment after school and any further support for collins baker, crome london p. Who is the genius that created things like the pulley systems and fulcrums? Question:“T.S Eliot’s Poetry Epitomises The Frustration And Impotence Of The Modern Individual.” Explore This Notion In Relation To Your Text Set For Study.Poems In Essay:- The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock (1915)- Rhapsody on a Windy Night (1915)- Preludes (1917)Notes:- Journey of the Magi (1925)- The Hollow Men (1927) Looking for part 2, read the next part of this study guide: HSC English Module B Study Guide: T.S. "Eliot, T. S." The Oxford Companion to English Literature. Development Of Mechanics: The Contribution Of Merton College. T.S Eliot is considered as one of the most important modernist poets. We’ll consider two of the poems set for study: The Love Song of J. Alfred Pr… Preludes - TS Eliot 1919 Words | 8 Pages. Oxford University Press 1995, Tradition and the Individual Talent (1917), The Awefull Battle of the Pekes and the Pollicles, T. S. Eliot Prize (Truman State University), https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Selected_Essays,_1917-1932&oldid=889781574, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, Religion and Literature (1935, added to the 1951 edition), Modern Education and the Classics (1935, added to the 1951 edition), This page was last edited on 27 March 2019, at 22:26. The During The Era Of Good Feeling, While Westward Expansion, My Career Goals Of Becoming An Applied Social Psychologist, Analysis Of The Atlanta Compromise Speech, The Secret Life Of Bees By Suzanne Collins, The True Meaning Of Life While Absorbing Nature 's Grace, Causes Of The Arab-Israeli Conflict In The Middle East, The Themes Of Betrayal And Redemption In The Kite Runner, A Judgement For Solomon : The D ' Hauteville Case, Analysis Of Orientalism, Criticizes And Confronts The Ideas Of Truth And Representation, By Edward Said, The Canadian Government Has Been Faced With A Decision, The School Dental Services At The Regional Hillah City / Babylon Province, The Cyber Spectrum Research And Technology Development Virtual Environment, Impact Of Social Media On Real Estate Business. What examples should we look for in the poems?  Further essays include The Metaphysical Poets (1921) in which Eliot argued that a "dissociation of sensibility" set in... due to the influence of ... Milton and Dryden. The Invention Of Murder, By Judith Flanders, Gender Differences In Communication Are A Set Of Rules, Effects Of Stigma Toward Mental Illnesses, Pbb And Mpls Complementary Technologies For Next Generation Carrier Ethernet Transport, Alcoholism Is The Addiction Of Alcoholic Liquor Or The Mental Illness, How Ceramic Cutting Tools Have Been Around For Over 100 Years, My freshman year at Cornell University, I was sitting in a Computer Programming and Meteorology, Pivotal Talent Pools and Role Challenges - Essay, Effects Of The Civil War On The United States, Marketing Stragety - Cobra Beer V/S Kingfisher, The Role Of Women Throughout The Play ' A Major Theme ', An Author's Life Is Reflected in Their Works, Agency Theory : Relationship Between Agents And The Business, The Impact Of Black Upward Mobility On The Corporate Sphere, Case Involving A Family Business Ownership Dispute Between Two Brothers, Racial Discrimination in America During the 1920's, Assertiveness As A Person Can Possess And Show, Marketing Goals And Objectives Of A New Zealand Appliance Market, In The Last 100 Years There Was A Major Challenges In The, Healthsouth Management Has Overstated Earnings, Project Technical Paper - Reliable Pharmaceutical Supply, How Relationship Marketing Impacts Consumer Buying Decisions, How Price Of Efds Machine Is Affecting Users From Acquiring And Implementing Efd System, Effective Persuasive Techniques Used By John Donne 's `` The Flea ``, The Ethics Case Seven : Spotlight On Pods, Effective School Leaders Must Be Dynamic And Ready, The Strategic Partnership Alliances Group, Protection Of Life And Safeguarding People, Analysis Of Toni Cade Bambara 's `` The `` Run ``, The Pandemic Of 1918-1919 Impacted Places Throughout The World, Analysis Of Chumash Renaissance : Indian Casinos, Education, And Cultural Politics, The Importance Of A Thorough Home Inspection, The Back & Neck Care Center 's Hierarchical Structure, The Male Characters View Women As Property That Belongs, The Role Of Metropolitan Filaret 's Divine Context And Ambiguity, Analysis Of Mark Twain 's ' The Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn ', Analysis Of The Film ' Saving Face, Hwei Lan Gao Or ' Ma '. T.S. These were all written within 3 years of the original 1932 publication. The first, or programmatic, phase of Eliot’s criticism ended with The Use of Poetry and the Use of Criticism (1933)—his Charles Eliot Norton lectures at Harvard. The content of his verse form every bit good as his poetic manner give elements of the modern motion that was celebrated during his clip. What is interesting is that the tone of this poem is not of wonderment, but of powerlessness. In fact, modernism was viewed as “ a rejection of traditional 19th-century … Eliot’s collection of essays on poetry and criticism covers such masters of verse as Dante and Blake as well as his critical views of poetic drama, rhetoric, blank verse and other critics such as Ben Johnson, Swinburne and Phillip Massinger. Eliot used The Waste Land and The Hollow Men to illustrate his feelings of a brutal age of war. Phillip W. Leininger. "Let us go then, you and I". This essay proposes to halt at the frontier of metaphysics or mysticism, and confine itself to such practical conclusions as can be applied by the responsible person interested in poetry. The content of his poem as well as his poetic style give elements of the modern movement that was famous during his time. The monologue describes the journey of the Magi to Bethlahem in search of spiritual pacification and is an account of Eliot’s own conversion to Anglican faith, making the journey and objective correlation for Eliot. In order to tell Beckett's story, Eliot creates a series of equally interesting … The Passage, Isaiah 14:12-23, Occurs Within A, Daniel Briggs 's Life At The Young Age Of 16, Price Matter At Customers : Drugs And Treatment For Chronic Myelogenous Leukemia ( Cml ), Demand Music Streaming And The Modern Music Industry, Grand Canyon University : A Christian University, School Of Thought Is Essential School For The Procedure Of Change Management, A melanoma is a fatal form of skin cancer tumor of the melanocyte a melanin-producing cell in the, Text Messaging: Its Impact on the Spelling Proficiency of the First Year Students, The Issue Of Abortion And Women 's Rights, When Diving Into The Details Of Gravitational Theories, William Shakespeare 's The Midsummer Night Dream, Henry Steck 's Ideologies- Corporatization Of Higher Education, The Death Penalty Should Be Used For An Advantage Against Criminals, In Today'S Progressing World, Technology Has Become Greatly, Relationship Between Friendship And Friendship, Analysis Of The Poem ' Fear Of Narrative And The Skittery Poem Of Our Moment ', Electronic Health Records : A Digital Version Of A Patient 's Paper Chart. Write a critical essay that demonstrates how your response to Eliot’s poetry changed and developed during the process of your critical study. Eliot Part 2 [Free Textual Analysis]. Original Uploader: smt. Texts on their own are interesting but when you compare them to other texts they become illuminating and dynamic. Eliot that appeared in the "Notes on Current Letters" section of the first volume of The Tyro (Spring 1921). The Cask Of Amontillado By Edgar Allan Poe, A Business Alliance Is An Open Ended Agreement That Governs The Co Operation Between Two Or More Companies, Analysis Of Toni Morrison And Anna Deveare Smith, Describe the sorts of problems that might occur when supporting learning activities and how to deal with these, Comparing William Shelley 's Frankenstein, A Low Power Bist Tpg For High Fault Coverage, Controversial Businessman And Political Figure Donald Trump, On April 29, 1974 A Relatively Unknown Freshman Member. Phillip W. Leininger. TS Eliot’s “The Hollow Men” is a revolutionary piece of poetry that embodies the post World War I zeitgeist. T.S. by Elizabeth Knowles. ABOUT THESE NOTES. Emotionally charged and deeply intellectual literature acts as the voice of an empathic society, reeked by disturbing uncertainty and consumed by an anxious paralysis. The Prevalence Of Autonomic Dysfunction And Fac Tors Affecting Can, Analysis Of Searle 's ' The Chinese Room Argument ', The Cfo And Cio Are Required To Approve The Project Charter, Contamination Of The Water Supply Of Flint, Childhood Is A Complex Concept Of Childhood, Community Service as a Graduation Requirement, Government Enforcement, Crime And The American Population, Analysis Of ' The Life Of William Wordsworth ' By John Worthen, Defining The Recruiting Coordinator By Designated Due Date, On The Dawn Of October 16Th, 1962, Began A 13-Day Standoff, Humberto Garcia Perhaps his best-known essay, “Tradition and the Individual Talent” was first published in 1919 and soon after included in The Sacred Wood: Essays on Poetry and Criticism (1920). The post-war society was one of hopelessness and isolation. What you need to do to achieve a Band 6 mark is present a well-structured response that demonstrates how the TEXTUAL INTEGRITY of the selection of Eliot’s poetry establishes its CANONICAL STATUS. Professor W. Raver Explore how time and place are used in … TS Eliot Essay Read More » This is an example of a high range response of a TS Eliot essay. Eliot notes several essays not collected in this edition but declares Selected Essays to already be 'bulky enough'. Introduction About the work: This webpage presents "The Lesson of Baudelaire," one of the two short essays by T.S.  A Dialogue on Dramatic Poetry was originally an addendum to Eliot's preface to Dryden's Essay of Dramatick Poesie (1928 reprint). Eliot: Poems essays are academic essays for citation. Support your points with reference to the poetry on your course.Tip: note the things that make this essay … Q40. A note on the American critic. Essay text: The poem was not first published until June 1915 in the poetic magazine Poetry: A Magazine of Verse in Chicago, USA.  Furthermore the modern poet ‘must be difficult’... ‘to force, to dislocate if necessary, language into his meaning’. Oxford University Press Inc. Eliot, T[homas] S[tearns]" The Oxford Companion to American Literature. The “Harvard Advocate” Poems(1907-1910) Prufrock and Other Observations (1917) Poems(1920) The Waste Land, 1922: the full authorised text, with notes The Waste Land: the manuscript, with Ezra Pound’s annotations TS Eliot on The Waste Land– comments on the poem by Eliot himself –––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– Now that we have considered themes and textual integrity in our study of Module B: T.S. A romantic aristocrat [George Wyndham]. Author Bored of Studies Downloads 1,953 Views 1,953 First release Oct 8, 2016 Last update Oct 8, 2016 Rating 0.00 star(s) 0 … These papers were written primarily by students and provide critical analysis of poems by T.S. As a critical study, the respondent must assess his work as a whole and be aware of the broader contextual impact of the work. This was in fact Eliot's first publication of a poem.  It was published in 1932 by his employers, Faber & Faber, costing 12/6 (2009: £32). 21026286 : Title: The Sacred Wood: Essays on Poetry and Criticism Contents: Introduction -- The perfect critic -- Imperfect critics: Swinburne as a critic. T. S. Eliot's Murder in the Cathedral tells the story of Thomas Beckett, a man who reigned as Archbishop of Canterbury during the 12th century in England until his death in 1170. Write a personal response to the poems by T. S. Eliot on your course. Eliot, T. S. (Thomas Stearns), 1888-1965: LoC No. T.S Eliot’s Poetic Voice.  Philip Massinger (1920) contains his aphorism "Immature poets imitate; mature poets steal". Preludes - TS Eliot Relevant Background Thomas Stearns [TS] Eliot was born in into a wealthy family in St Louis, Missouri, America in 1888 He became a British citizen at the age of 39 in 1927. Reversing Type 2 Diabetes : Is It Possible? Socratic Justice And The Trial And Death Of Socrates, The Policy Of Appeasement During The Outbreak Of War, Identification Of Conserved Regulatory Motif, William Jefferson Blythe Lll Was Born On August 19, 1946, An Analysis Of Solomon Northup 's 12 Years A Slave, We Are Wasteful People Of The United States Waste A Lot Of Natural Resources, Family And Child Development : Toddler Observation Study, Race And Crime Of The Criminal Justice System, Metro Transit And The Better Bus Stop Engagement, A Voice Guidance System For Autonomous Robots, Literary. Let’s have a go. Here is the majority of his famous essay “What Dante Means to Me” (hence my own “What Eliot Means to Me”), which can be found in his collection of essays, To Criticize the Critic and Other Writings. Eliot's work fundamentally changed literary thinking and Selected Essays provides both an overview and an in-depth examination of his theory. This response is for the 2013 English HSC. , In addition to his poetry, by 1932, Eliot was already accepted as one of English Literature's most important critics. Band 5/6 essay for Module B, T.S. Eliot, we need to think about how textual analysis supports these ideas. In our first article on TS Eliot, we discussed how to analyse his poetry. Oxford University Press Inc. Oxford Reference Online. How Does It Affect The Basic Structures Of Chromosomes? The definite reads, if you do not want to go through all the essays, are the essays "Dante", "Hamlet and his Problems" and "A Dialogue on Dramatic Poetry". Considered one of the 20th century's major poets, he is a central figure in English-language Modernist poetry. Ts eliot essays for maid of honor speech As has been high lighted recently by research and development of research in developing and imple mentation of computer tech nology essays ts eliot can enhance your ability to coach yourself through the s was red, white, and indigenous indian strains in the process, they can continue to improve jeaa. Revision Of The Critique Of HardinbS bLifeboat Ethicsb: Dreams : What Does A Person 's Dream Say About Their Personality And Their Emotions? Overall Rating: Download . The speaker of T.S. These essays offer an education. Case Study : ' Critical Thinking ' Action ', A Office Director Of Organizational Policy And Governance, Anorexia Nervosa (Nutrition and Psychology Related), Emergency Management And The Homeland Security Information Network, Working With Two Boys Who Have Learning Difficulties And Behavioral Problems, A Caucasian Male Who Worked During The Construction Field For 35 Years, Illegal Drugs : Source And Solution And It 's The Problem, Role Of Television Advertising Of Lifestyle Products On Purchase Behaviour Of Youth And Enhancing Their Lifestyle, The Factors Associated With Youth Homelessness And Arrest, By Kim Fielding And Cheryl Forchuk, Industry- I Have Worked In Retail Management All Of My, Financial Rewards For Living Organ Donors, The Salience Of Humanity And Self Actualized People, The Rise of China Ts Eliot Critical Essay "How has your research into TS Eliot's life and the opinions of ONE critic enriched your understanding of an aspect of The Love Song of J Alfred Prufrock?" Eliot really outdid himself with his reviews of the literature that he was surrounded by. Eliot’s “Journey of the Magi” is one of the magi of the title, who delineates his arduous journey to witness the birth of Christ. English (Advanced) 3 Pages 1 Student Found this helpful HSC - Higher School Certificate Year 12 Essay / Project Year: Pre-2017. T.S Eliot is considered as one of the most of import modernist poets. July 11, 2019 by Essay Writer. The Syrian Uprising is an, 4ps and How the Firm Position Their Products for Maximum Competitive Advantage in the Marketplace, Legislative Law S.1832 : Pay Workers A Living Wage Act. These essays are also great specimens of the English review-essay; as with James, Eliot's conquest of literary London was partly due to his mastery of the lofty, authoritative "we" of canonic critcism. PDF | On Aug 4, 2017, Mariwan Hasan published T. S. Eliot: Critical Essays | Find, read and cite all the research you need on ResearchGate Eliot Theme of Death in the Poetry of Dylan Thomas W.B. In this position he was instrumental in the reviving interest in the long‐neglected Jacobean playwrights. "Dante" is a beuatiful study on both the "Divina Comedia" and "Vita Nouva".  For Lancelot Andrewes (1926), examines Andrewes, a 17th-century Anglican bishop whose Eliot considers an important figure in history of the church, distinguished for the quality of his thoughts and prose. TS Eliot Module B Essay. Popol Vuh James D. Hart, ed., rev. What Makes A Relationship With Success And Failure? Textual Integrity and Canonical Status. ... TS Eliot Poems. Journey of the Magi’ has been penned down by Nobel prize winner TS Eliot an is a contrast of experiences based on the nativity of Christ. Eliot, T[homas] S[tearns]" The Oxford Companion to American Theatre, 3rd edn., Gerald Bordman and Thomas S. Hischak, eds., Oxford University Press 2004. An Ethnographic Study On American Ethnic Identity, Healthcare Reform : The Most Noble Of Professions, Sexual Intercourse Within The Human Species, The Last Seven Weeks Of Business Research Methods, The Yellow Wallpaper By Charlotte Perkins Gilman, The Ethics Of The Arizona Peace Officer Standards And Training Board, A Raisin Of The Sun By Lorraine Hansberry And Eveline, Citizenship For The 12 Million Illegal Immigrants, Apprehension Of Dying : Palliative Care And The Steps, Teaching Disabilities And Academic Learning Disabilities, The Use Of Paramilitary Tactics Within The Police Force, Effects Of Colonialism On Gender Equality, Nursing Process : Ethical Decision Making, All Children Are Given The Same Opportunity, Nursing Professionalism And The Profession Of Nursing, Life And The Truth Behind Of Siddhartha, Phaedrus, And Oedipus The King, There 's Nothing More Dangerous Than Someone Who Wants For Make The World A Better Place, The Role Of Corporate Social Responsibility On Csr, How Advertising Affects The Common Man 's Opinion On Most Products, How Media And Electronics Can Be Good For Not Only Self Esteem, Examining The Place Of The Russian Minority, The Marxist Leader Of The Cuban Delegation, Personal Analysis Of Personal Environmental Analysis, The Uniform Crime Records And The Federal Bureau Of The Chiefs Of Police ( Iacp ), Analysis Of The Poem ' Rocking Horse Winner ', Challenges Faced By Entrepreneurs Lower Their Self Confidence, The Effect Of Light Intensity And Light Wavelength On Photosynthesis, The Great Human Tumor : Earth 's Human Overpopulation Crisis, Csr Practices Of Indian Corporate Houses : Hrd Intervention, The Effects Of Bilingualism On Multiple Difference Areas, The Criminal Justice System Is Not Child Focused, Obamacare Is An Affordable Health Care Plan, The American Dream And The Trouble With Diversity By Walter Benn Michaels, Drug Use And Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder ( Adhd ), Disease, High Blood Cholesterol And Brain Diseases, President Dwight Eisenhower 's Farewell Address Or His Warning, William Shakespeare 's Much Ado About Nothing, Cognitive Strategies And The Risk Of Emotional Contagion, Women 's Choices Are Being Taken From Them, Professional Knowledge : Cognitive Development, Pregnancy Among Adolescents And Teenage Pregnancy, The Federal Reserve System Is A Banking System Of The United States, Public State Formation And Stimulation Of Increased Ethnic Conflict, Usage Of Restriction Enzymes Of Dna Fingerprinting, Richard Nixon : The Second Of Five Children, Japan 's Economic Success During The World War II, The Effects Of Contaminants On The Rate Of Cellular Respiration, The Basic Model Of Visual Cryptography And The Extended Model, Elder Abuse As Defined By The Center For Disease Control And Prevention, The Grotesque Of Grace And Its Implications On Morality, Technology And Its Impact On Student Life, The Price And Availability Of The Product, Leadership Experience Describe Your Leadership Experiences, Health Care Marketing Plan For Lee County, Classroom Interactions Between Teachers And Students, Analysis Of The Movie ' The Thin Red Line ', Piaget Of The Infant Cognitive Development, Racism Is Funny, By Co Creator Of South Park, And The Simpsons, How Technology Helps With The Sales Process And How It Can Develop A Trust Based Relationship Between Businesses, Designing A Building Or Interior Design For Lure Customers. More and more people began to see the meaningless existence of human life and as a result, became desensitized to human emotion and existed in a state of limbo. Eliot (specifically The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock, Rhapsody of … T.S Eliot's Poetic Voice essay sample. "T. S. Eliot" Oxford Dictionary of Quotations. Today China is widely notorious for its large dominance in world affairs, Managing All Operations At The Restaurant, Why It 's Important For Digitally Transform Your Business. An essay written for module b, critical study of texts. Substances Include Those Like Stressful Life Events Such, A List Of Robert Peel 's Twelve Standards Of Policing, Dave Pelzer, A Non Fiction Book Based On The True Story Of One Such Child, Analysis Of John Stuart Mill 's ' Veil Of Ignorance ' And ' The Classic Social Contract Theory, Is the conflict in Syria a civil war, an insurgency or a proxy conflict?